First Round (Quarterbacks)

1. Michigan Panthers – QB Shea Patterson
2. Tampa Bay Bandits – QB Jordan Ta’amu
3. Philadelphia Stars – QB Bryan Scott
4. New Jersey Generals – QB Ben Holmes
5. Houston Gamblers – QB Clayton Thorson
6. Birmingham Stallions – QB Alex McGough
7. Pittsburgh Maulers – QB Kyle Lauetta 
8. New Orleans Breakers – QB Kyle Sloter

Second Round (EDGE Rushers)

1. New Orleans Breakers – EDGE Davis Bellamy 
2. Pittsburgh Maulers – EDGE Carlo Kemp
3. Birmingham Stallions – EDGE Aaron Adeoye 
4. Houston Gamblers – EDGE Chris Odom
5. New Jersey Generals – EDGE Bryson Young
6. Philadelphia Stars – EDGE Freedom Akinmoladun 
7. Tampa Bay Bandits – EDGE Mekhi Brown 
8. Michigan Panthers – EDGE Adewale Adeoye 

Third Round (EDGE Rushers)

1. Michigan Panthers -EDGE Cavon Walker 
2. Tampa Bay Bandits – EDGE Michael Scott
3. Philadelphia Stars – EDGE Gus Cumber 
4. New Jersey Generals – EDGE Kolin Hill
5. Houston Gamblers – EDGE Ahmad Gooden
6. Birmingham Stallions – EDGE Chauncey Haney
7. Pittsburgh Maulers – EDGE Nasir Player
8. New Orleans Breakers – EDGE Anree Saint-Amour 

Fourth Round (EDGE Rushers)

1. New Orleans Breakers – EDGE James Folston Jr 
2. Pittsburgh Maulers – EDGE Eric Assoua 
3. Birmingham Stallions – EDGE Seth Thomas 
4. Houston Gamblers – EDGE Drequan Brown
5. New Jersey Generals – EDGE Malik Hamner 
6. Philadelphia Stars – EDGE Carroll Phillips 
7. Tampa Bay Bandits – EDGE Adam Shuler
8. Michigan Panthers – EDGE Chase Demoor
9. *New Orleans Breakers – EDGE Nigel Chavis (Compensatory Pick)
10. *Birmingham Stallions – EDGE Jonathan Newsome (Compensatory Pick)

Fifth Round (Offensive Tackles)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – OT Chidi Okeke
2. Birmingham Stallions – OT Darius Harper 
3. Houston Gamblers – OT Brandon Hitner 
4. New Orleans Breakers – OT Paul Adams 
5. Michigan Panthers – OT Keith Williams
6. New Jersey Generals – OT Garrett McGhin
7. Philadelphia Stars – OT Blake Alan Camper
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – OT Tyler Catalina 

Sixth Round (Offensive Tackles)

1. Tampa Bay Bandits – OT Corbin Kaufusi 
2. Philadelphia Stars – OT Michael Rodriguez III
3. New Jersey Generals – OT Calvin Ashley
4. Michigan Panthers – OT Teton Saltes
5. New Orleans Breakers – OT Donnell Greene
6. Houston Gamblers – OT Avery Gennesy
7. Birmingham Stallions – OT O’Shea Dugas 
8. Pittsburgh Maulers – OT Isaiah Battle

Seventh Round (Offensive Tackles)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – OT Charles Baldwin
2. Birmingham Stallions – OT Justice Powers
3. Houston Gamblers – OT John Yarbrough
4. New Orleans Breakers – OT Marquis Lucas
5. Michigan Panthers – OT Joshua Dunlop
6. New Jersey Generals – OT Terry Poole
7. Philadelphia Stars – OT Jacob Paul Burton
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – OT Juwann Bushell-Beatty
9. *Birmingham Stallions – OT Matthew Snow (Compensatory Pick)
10. *Michigan Panthers – OT Joshua Taylor (Compensatory Pick)

Eighth Round (Cornerbacks)

1. Tampa Bay Bandits – CB Derrick Abrams Jr
2. Philadelphia Stars – CB Channing Stribling
3. New Jersey Generals – CB De’Vante Bausby
4. Michigan Panthers – CB Tino Ellis
5. New Orleans Breakers – CB Adonis Alexander
6. Houston Gamblers – CB Jamar Summers
7. Birmingham Stallions – CB Brian Allen
8. Pittsburgh Maulers – CB Ajene Harris

Ninth Round (Cornerbacks)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – CB Terrell Bonds
2. Birmingham Stallions – CB Tae Hayes
3. Houston Gamblers – CB Will Likely
4. New Orleans Breakers – CB Derrick Jones
5. Michigan Panthers – CB Jameson Houston
6. New Jersey Generals – CB Trae Elston
7. Philadelphia Stars – CB Marcus Lewis
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – CB Davante Davis

Tenth Round (Cornerbacks)

1. Tampa Bay Bandits – CB Christian Campbell
2. Philadelphia Stars – CB Mazzi Wilkins
3. New Jersey Generals – CB David Rivers
4. Michigan Panthers – CB Dominique Martin
5. New Orleans Breakers – CB Manny Patterson
6. Houston Gamblers – CB Howard Wilson
7. Birmingham Stallions – CB Bryan Mills
8. Pittsburgh Maulers – CB Prince Robinson

Eleventh Round (Cornerbacks)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – CB Jaylon McClain-Sapp
2. Birmingham Stallions – CB Lorenzo Burns
3. Houston Gamblers – CB Jerry Cantave
4. New Orleans Breakers – CB Ja’Len Embry
5. Michigan Panthers – CB Jalin Burrell
6. New Jersey Generals – CB DeJuan Neal
7. Philadelphia Stars – CB Bradley Sylve
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – CB Rashard Causey Jr
9. New Orleans Breakers – CB Ike Brown

Twelfth Round (Quarterbacks)

1. New Orleans Breakers – QB Zach Smith
2. Pittsburgh Maulers – QB Josh Love
3. Birmingham Stallions – QB J’Mar Davis-Smith
4. Houston Gamblers – QB Kenji Bahar
5. New Jersey Generals – QB De’Andre Johnson
6. Philadelphia Stars – QB Case Cookus
7. Tampa Bay Bandits – QB Brady White
8. Michigan Panthers – QB Paxton Lynch

Thirteenth Round (Wide Receivers)

1. Birmingham Stallions – WR Victor Bolden Jr
2. Houston Gamblers – WR Isaiah Zuber
3. New Orleans Breakers – WR Shawn Poindexter
4. Pittsburgh Maulers – WR Jeff Thomas
5. Tampa Bay Bandits – WR Eli Rogers
6. Michigan Panthers – WR Quincy Adeboyejo
7. New Jersey Generals – WR KaVonte Turpin
8. Philadelphia Stars – WR Devin Gray

Fourteenth Round (Wide Receivers)

1. Philadelphia Stars – WR Jordan Suell
2. New Jersey Generals – WR J’Mon Moore
3. Michigan Panthers – WR Lance Lenoir
4. Tampa Bay Bandits – WR Derrick Willies
5. Pittsburgh Maulers – WR Bailey Gaither
6. New Orleans Breakers – WR Johnnie Dixon
7. Houston Gamblers – WR JoJo Ward
8. Birmingham Stallions – WR Emmanuel Hall

Fifteenth Round (Wide Receivers)

1. Birmingham Stallions – WR Osirus Mitchell
2. Houston Gamblers – WR Anthony Ratliff-Williams
3. New Orleans Breakers – WR Jonathan Adams
4. Pittsburgh Maulers – WR Branden Mack
5. Tampa Bay Bandits – WR Derrick Dillon
6. Michigan Panthers – WR Jeff Badet
7. New Jersey Generals – WR Darrius Shepherd
8. Philadelphia Stars – WR Brennan Eagles

Sixteenth Round (Wide Receivers)

1. Philadelphia Stars – WR Diondre Overton
2. New Jersey Generals – WR Christopher Platt Jr
3. Michigan Panthers – WR Ray Bolden
4. Tampa Bay Bandits – WR Jordan Lasley
5. Pittsburgh Maulers – WR Delvon Hardaway
6. New Orleans Breakers – WR Taywon Taylor
7. Houston Gamblers – WR Tyler Simmons
8. Birmingham Stallions – WR Peyton Ramzy

Seventeenth Round (Wide Receivers)

1. Birmingham Stallions – WR Manasseh Bailey
2. Houston Gamblers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
3. New Orleans Breakers – WR Chad Williams
4. Pittsburgh Maulers – WR Tre Walker
5. Tampa Bay Bandits – WR John Franklin III
6. Michigan Panthers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
7. New Jersey Generals – WR Randy Satterfield
8. Philadelphia Stars – WR Maurice Alexander
9. *Tampa Bay Bandits – WR Vinny Papale (Compensatory Pick)

Eighteenth Round (Safeties)

1. Philadelphia Stars – S Jack Tocho
2. New Jersey Generals – S Shalom Luani
3. Michigan Panthers – S Orion Stewart
4. Tampa Bay Bandits – S Obi Melifonwu
5. Pittsburgh Maulers – S Arnold Tarpley III
6. New Orleans Breakers – S Dartez Jacobs
7. Houston Gamblers – S Andrew Soroh
8. Birmingham Stallions – S Christian McFarland

Nineteenth Round (Safeties)

1. Birmingham Stallions – S Tyree Robinson
2. Houston Gamblers – S Manny Bunch
3. New Orleans Breakers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
4. Pittsburgh Maulers – S Bryce Torneden
5. Tampa Bay Bandits – S Anthony Cioffi
6. Michigan Panthers – S Kieron Williams
7. New Jersey Generals – S Dragon Askew-Henry
8. Philadelphia Stars – S Cody Brown
9. *Philadelphia Stars – S Ladarius Wiley (Compensatory Pick)

Twentieth Round (Centers)

1. New Jersey Generals – C Jake Lacina
2. Michigan Panthers – C Sean Richard Pollard
3. Tampa Bay Bandits – C Bruno Reagan
4. Philadelphia Stars – C Sean Brown
5. Birmingham Stallions – C Jordan McCray
6. Pittsburgh Maulers – C Nicholas Falah
7. New Orleans Breakers – C Jared Thomas
8. Houston Gamblers – C Nick Buchanan
9. *Pittsburgh Maulers – C Brayden Patton (Compensatory Pick)

Twenty-First Round (Inside Linebackers)

1. Houston Gamblers – LB Beniquez Brown
2. New Orleans Breakers – LB Jerod Fernandez
3. Pittsburgh Maulers – LB EJ Ejiya
4. Birmingham Stallions – LB Scooby Wright
5. Philadelphia Stars – LB Josh Banderas
6. Tampa Bay Bandits – LB Christian Sam
7. Michigan Panthers – LB Justin Hughes
8. New Jersey Generals – LB Chris Orr
9. *Houston Gamblers – LB Reggie Northrup (Compensatory Pick)
10. *Birmingham Stallions – LB Jason Ferris (Compensatory Pick)
11. *Michigan Panthers – LB Taiwan Jones (Compensatory Pick)

Twenty-Second Round (Guards)

1. New Orleans Breakers – G Steven Rowzee
2. Pittsburgh Maulers – G Vadal Alexander
3. Birmingham Stallions – G Cameron Hunt
4. Houston Gamblers – G Tyler Higby
5. New Jersey Generals – G Mike Brown
6. Philadelphia Stars – G Jackson Brown
7. Tampa Bay Bandits – G Fred Lauina
8. Michigan Panthers – G Marquee Harrell

Twenty-Third Round (Guards)

1. Michigan Panthers – G Daishawn Dixon
2. Tampa Bay Bandits – G Damien Mama
3. Philadelphia Stars – G Paul Nosworthy
4. New Jersey Generals – G Evan Heim
5. Houston Gamblers – G Terronne Prescod
6. Birmingham Stallions – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
7. Pittsburgh Maulers – G Jon Dietzen
8. New Orleans Breakers – G Liam Dobson
9. *New Orleans Breakers – G Jalen Allen (Compensatory Pick)

Twenty-Fourth Round (Defensive/Nose Tackles)

1. Michigan Panthers – DT TJ Carter
2. Tampa Bay Bandits – DT Daylon Mack
3. Philadelphia Stars – DT Mike Barnett
4. New Jersey Generals – DT Destiny Vaeao
5. Houston Gamblers – DT Cory Thomas
6. Birmingham Stallions – DT Willie Yarbary
7. Pittsburgh Maulers – DT Olive Sagapolu
8. New Orleans Breakers – DT Shakir Soto

Twenty-Fifth Round (Defensive/Nose Tackles)

1. New Orleans Breakers – DT Kamilo Tongamoa
2. Pittsburgh Maulers – DT Boogie Roberts
3. Birmingham Stallions – DT Haston Adams
4. Houston Gamblers – DT Tomasi Laulile
5. New Jersey Generals – DT Toby Johnson
6. Philadelphia Stars – DT Chris Nelson
7. Tampa Bay Bandits – DT Reggie Howard
8. Michigan Panthers – DT Jaquan Bailey

Twenty-Sixth Round (Defensive/Nose Tackles)

1. Michigan Panthers – DT Kyshonn Tyson
2. Tampa Bay Bandits – DT John Atkins
3. Philadelphia Stars – DT Jerome Johnson
4. New Jersey Generals – DT Kalani Vakameilalo
5. Houston Gamblers – DT Domenique Davis
6. Birmingham Stallions – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
7. Pittsburgh Maulers – DT Jeremiah Pharms Jr
8. New Orleans Breakers – DT Connor Christian
9. *New Orleans Breakers – Christopher Okoye (Compensatory Pick)

Twenty-Seventh Round (Running Backs/Fullbacks)

1. Tampa Bay Bandits – RB BJ Emmons
2. Philadelphia Stars – RB Darnell Holland
3. New Jersey Generals – RB Mike Weber
4. Michigan Panthers – RB Steve Scott III
5. New Orleans Breakers – RB Larry Rose III
6. Houston Gamblers – RB Dalyn Dawkins
7. Birmingham Stallions – RB Tony Brooks-James
8. Pittsburgh Maulers – RB Garret Groshek

Twenty-Eighth Round (Running Backs/Fullbacks)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – RB De’Veon Smith
2. Birmingham Stallions – RB CJ Marable
3. Houston Gamblers – RB Mark Thompson
4. New Orleans Breakers – RB Jordan Ellis
5. Michigan Panthers – RB Reggie Corbin
6. New Jersey Generals – RB Trey Williams
7. Philadelphia Stars – RB Matt Colburn II
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – RB Juwan Washington

Twenty-Ninth Round (Outside Linebackers)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – OLB Tyson Graham
2. Birmingham Stallions – OLB DeMarquis Gates
3. Houston Gamblers – OLB Akeem Victor
4. New Orleans Breakers – OLB Diondre Wallace
5. Michigan Panthers – OLB Terry Myrick
6. New Jersey Generals – OLB D’Juan Hines
7. Philadelphia Stars – OLB Jordan Moore
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – OLB Emmanuel Beal

Thirtieth Round (Outside Linebackers)

1. Tampa Bay Bandits – OLB Greg Reaves
2. Philadelphia Stars – OLBTe’Von Coney
3. New Jersey Generals – OLB Tim Walton Jr
4. Michigan Panthers – OLB Frank Ginda
5. New Orleans Breakers – OLB Vontae Diggs
6. Houston Gamblers – OLB Donald Payne
7. Birmingham Stallions – OLB Terrill Hanks
8. Pittsburgh Maulers – OLB Malcolm Howard

Thirty-First Round (Outside Linebackers)

1. Pittsburgh Maulers – OLB Kyahva Tezino
2. Birmingham Stallions – OLB Brody Buck
3. Houston Gamblers – OLB Drew Lewis
4. New Orleans Breakers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
5. Michigan Panthers – OLB Tre Threat
6. New Jersey Generals – OLB Angelo Garbutt
7. Philadelphia Stars – OLB Solomon Wise
8. Tampa Bay Bandits – Passed (Compensatory Pick)

Thirty-Second Round (Kickers)

1. Philadelphia Stars – K Matt Mengel
2. New Jersey Generals – K Nick Rose
3. Michigan Panthers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
4. Tampa Bay Bandits – K Brandon Wright
5. Pittsburgh Maulers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
6. New Orleans Breakers – K Austin MacGinnis
7. Houston Gamblers – K Nick Vogel
8. Birmingham Stallions – K Brandon Aubrey

Thirty-Third Round (Punters)

1. Birmingham Stallions – P Colby Wadman
2. Houston Gamblers – P Andrew Galitz
3. New Orleans Breakers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
4. Pittsburgh Maulers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
5. Tampa Bay Bandits – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
6. Michigan Panthers – P Michael Carrizosa
7. New Jersey Generals – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
8. Philadelphia Stars – Passed (Compensatory Pick)

Thirty-Fourth Round (Tight Ends/H-Backs)

1. Houston Gamblers – TE Brandon Barnes
2. New Orleans Breakers – TE Sal Cannella
3. Pittsburgh Maulers – TE Matt Seybert
4. Birmingham Stallions – TE Cary Angeline
5. Philadelphia Stars – TE Bug Howard
6. Tampa Bay Bandits – TE Cheyenne O’Grady
7. Michigan Panthers – TE Joseph Magnifico
8. New Jersey Generals – TE Braedon Bowman
9. *Houston Gamblers – TE Julian Allen (Compensatory Pick)
10. *Tampa Bay Bandits – TE De’Quan Hampton (Compensatory Pick)
11. *Michigan Panthers – H-B La’Michael Pettway (Compensatory Pick)
12. *New Jersey Generals – TE Nicholas Truesdale (Compensatory Pick)

Thirty-Fifth Round (Long Snappers)

1. New Jersey Generals – LS Scott Flanick
2. Michigan Panthers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
3. Tampa Bay Bandits – LS Ryan Disalvo
4. Philadelphia Stars – LS Ryan Navarro
5. Birmingham Stallions – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
6. Pittsburgh Maulers – LS Mitchell Fraboni
7. New Orleans Breakers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)
8. Houston Gamblers – Passed (Compensatory Pick)